Anthony's Pizza

Anthony’s pizza has been our pizza place since it opened. It’s the best New York style pizza since coming from New York City. My granddaughter loves it and she says this is our tradition to go eat after church. The food is delicious and the service is amazing. Yes sometimes they’re very busy but it’s only because they’re very good. It’s worth the wait. Reason I’m reviewing now is because my granddaughter Said we have to review and give them a 5 star.

I’ve been coming to Anthony’s Pizza for years, and they never disappoint! This time I ordered the small special calzone… but it was definitely not small and it was absolutely delicious. I also had the BBQ wings with blue cheese, and they were so good. For dessert, I got my favorite — a cannoli — and Kassidy, our server, actually made it from scratch herself! She was amazing the entire afternoon: super sweet, attentive, and made the whole experience even better. Anthony’s continues to be one of my go-to spots. Highly recommend!

The best shrimp scamp and lasagna I’ve EVER had!! The owners are so nice and welcoming and they always make everything with love. They will customize your dish if you want it a certain way, and add extra to anything. I mean look at the size of the cucumber and tomatoes on my huge side salad! Always happy to come hear and be a regular! Dine in experience is always relaxing and preferred over take out. Not saying that the food quality differs. Just the experience. Food is always good where it’s there or at home.

I was visiting the Altamonte Springs area after moving out of the area a few years ago and this spot was always my favorite for pizza. I walked in and ordered a chicken pesto pizza and asked that tomato sauce be added with the pesto and the cashier stated, “let me check to see if we can do this?” When she returned, she stated it will be $2 to add sauce to an already expensive pizza. The large pizza ended being close to $30. ln all honesty, I felt that charging for tomato sauce was ridiculous. The pizza took about 25 minutes to prepare and it is good to know that the pizza is prepared fresh and they have the authentic pizza ovens. I appreciated while I was waiting that several times the staff at the counter did check in with me on the status of my order. Now! Let’s talk about the taste. This is bar none amazing pizza! Loaded with toppings and delicious! The pizza does not disappoint. (Very clean restroom as well)

Anthony’s Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant delivers that comforting, old-school warmth the moment you walk in. The place is spotless, clean, organized, and inviting the kind of environment that tells you they take pride in every corner of the restaurant. Our server, Kassidy, carried the whole experience with a bright smile and genuine attentiveness. She was helpful without hovering, quick without rushing, and made sure everything felt easy and enjoyable. Service like that is rare these days, and she elevates the meal from good to memorable. Highly recommended.

HAWAIIAN: Pizza here is awesome: they really load up the pizza with toppings & aren’t stingy with them. Staff is wonderful & very welcoming. Atmosphere seems like what you’d expect from a good Italian spot. We got the Hawaiian pizza with chicken. A small pizza can feed 2 people easily. Bathrooms are clean. Would definitely get another pizza here!

Anthony’s Pizza has been one of my favorite spots for years! Every time I went, the pizza was always fresh, flavorful, and truly authentic Italian. The crust was just right, the toppings generous, and the taste unbeatable — it became my go-to lunch and even my afternoon treat after work. On top of the amazing food, the customer service was excellent. The staff always made me feel welcome, and that friendly atmosphere made the experience even better. If you’re looking for quality pizza with great service, Anthony’s is definitely a place to try. Highly recommend!

I have ordered from them a couple of times. The pizza I receive has been fresh and, most importantly, full of the toppings I request. I ordered the cheese pizza and added mushrooms and meatballs. It was absolutely loaded with the good stuff. Will definitely be ordering from them again.